A Congressman Proposes Another Avenue to Gun Control

by
posted on June 10, 2022
Donaldbeyer

Amid the continuing misguided cry to “just do something” following a handful of high-profile mass murders, one U.S. congressman apparently believes the key to stopping such violence is hitting law-abiding gun purchasers squarely in the pocketbook.

Rep. Donald Beyer (D-Va.) is proposing a 1,000% excise tax on what he calls “AR-15-style” guns. Beyer, a member of the U.S. House of Representatives’ Ways and Means Committee, sees the move as an alternative way to effectively ban semi-automatic firearms.

“What it’s intended to do is provide another creative pathway to actually make some sensible gun control happen,” Beyer told Insider.com. “We think that a 1,000% fee on assault weapons is just the kind of restrictive measure that creates enough fiscal impact to qualify for reconciliation.”

Since the proposal is a tax measure, it could bypass the U.S. Senate’s 60-vote threshold to bypass a filibuster, making it much easier to successfully push through that body than more straightforward gun-control measures, which typically fail with the Senate’s current makeup.

Of course, such a tax on any firearm would be devastating for those wishing to purchase common semi-automatic rifles. For those short on math skills (I had to use a calculator.), the tax on a mid-range $1,500 AR-15 would be $15,000, resulting in a total price of $16,500.

The move brings to mind the famous statement of U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Marshall, who in 1819 wrote: “The power to tax involves the power to destroy.” In this case, the power to tax would involve the power to destroy the ability to purchase such firearms for most law-abiding gun owners without affecting criminals, which studies have proven typically get their firearms in other manners than in lawful sales from licensed dealers.

A study by Bureau of Justice Statistics that looked at state and federal inmates found that only a small fraction of them acquired firearms through the type of retail sale that would be subject to the proposed tax. The overwhelming majority of offenders obtained firearms through “friends or family” or “street/illegal sources.”

Consequently, the burden of Beyer’s tax would fall on law-abiding gun owners, who bear absolutely no blame for criminal misuse of firearms. Some of the burden would also fall on gun manufacturers, who would almost certainly see the sales of semi-automatic rifles tumble.

Additionally, while the burden would be prohibitive for most Americans, it would be even greater for low-income Americans who want to practice their Second Amendment rights—often in very dangerous areas where they need the right to keep and bear arms the most.

Of course, Beyer’s scheme is nothing new, as politicians across the country have proposed such measures before, despite the fact that they largely affect only Americans who behave in a lawful manner. Seattle passed a $25 additional tax on guns and ammunition several years ago, which hurt both law-abiding gun purchasers and retailers. Cooke County, Ill., also passed a law placing a $25 tax on guns and 5 cent tax on each round of centerfire ammo sold, along with a 1-cent tax on rimfire cartridges. The tax was later upheld by a state court of appeals.

Fortunately, the state Supreme Court, in 2021, flatly rejected the tax by a unanimous 6-0 vote. At the time, one justice wrote that the state constitution “plainly states that the right of the individual to keep and bear arms is subject only to the police power, not the power to tax.”

In the end, Beyer’s extremely punitive tax scheme, like any other plan to tax firearms protected by the Second Amendment out of the financial reach of most Americans, is misguided, as it targets only the law-abiding, leaving violent criminals to do what they do. Of course, the same can also be said of nearly every other gun-control proposal currently under consideration in Congress and in the states.

Latest

48548467152_39f9eaba7f_k.jpg
48548467152_39f9eaba7f_k.jpg

Gun-Control Groups Present a Demand List to Biden

A long list of gun-control groups recently signed a letter telling President Biden that his gun-control actions are not enough. In his upcoming State of the Union Address, they want him to agree to much more.

Gun Skills: Shooting from Retreat

Shooting at a stationary target doesn't represent a defensive situation; it's important to "get off the X." But even when we do, we often forget rearward motion as an option.

Gun Review: Springfield Armory DS Prodigy

The DS Prodigy provides the same magazine capacity as most striker-fired polymer pistols; however, it also provides the familiarity–and much-better trigger–of the 1911.

Gun Owners Aren't to Blame For Surging Violent Crime

Increases in violent crime are the result of a number of factors, yet some politicians and media members are blaming lawful gun owners. Here is why.

NRA-Backed Constitutional Carry Introduced in Florida

Another state looks to advance freedom for its citizens.

Confiscation in Canada

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's authoritarian zeal to disarm his citizens is a warning to any free people–and it shows how fundamentally important our constitutional protections are.

Interests



Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.