America’s Worst Gun-Carry Law Just Went Into Effect

posted on September 1, 2022
New York National Guard courtesy Flickr

As the calendar turned to September, New York’s new web of “gun-free” (aka, “sensitive places”) zones went into effect; as a result, it is now illegal for even New Yorkers who have carry permits to bring their concealed, self-defense firearms almost anywhere they want to go.

New York state legislators wrote and passed these new restrictions—which extend from Times Square to churches to parks to even privately owned stores that don’t specifically say armed citizens can carry their firearms—as a pushback against the U.S. Supreme Court ruling NYSRPA v. Bruen. In NYSRPA, the high court ruled that, yes indeed, Americans’ Second Amendment freedom does extend outside their homes.

Now, in New York, if someone who obtained a carry permit accidentally walks into a “sensitive area,” they could face a felony charge—and then potentially lose their Second Amendment rights for life.

As we previously wrote, “Even if you don’t live in New York, this is important ... . Anti-gun lawmakers in other states may look to New York to determine if they should follow Albany’s lead of thumbing its legislative nose at the highest level of the judiciary when determining how to adjust their own laws.”

New York’s new gun-control law also requires in-person interviews for those seeking pistol permits; a 16-hour, in-person, live curriculum; and two hours of a live-fire range training course.

Those “applying” for their rights must also provide the licensing officer with four character references and “a list of former and current social media accounts of the applicant from the past three years,” so the state can check each person’s character. Okay then, will some partisan licensing official use this as an opportunity to bar people from their rights because of political comments made on social media? Maybe. The potential for abuse here is hard to quantify.

Much of the media is now reporting that on “electronic billboards across New York’s Times Square, city authorities are posting new signs proclaiming the bustling crossroads a ‘Gun Free Zone.’” But the list of no-gun zones is actually so broad it even includes parks, such as New York state’s Catskill (700,000 acres) and Adirondack Parks (6 million acres). About 137,000 New Yorkers live in the boundaries of the state’s Adirondack Park, and about 50,000 live in the state’s Catskill Park. So are these nearly 200,000 residents now denied their Second Amendment rights even though the U.S. Supreme Court just affirmed that they have the right to carry outside their homes?

What about the many people who travel to these beautiful locations?

I camped in the Adirondack Park in late August—just a few days before this law took effect. I was carrying. I do have a permit to carry in the state. Now that it is September, I would risk a felony conviction if I carry there today. I thought about this as I set a 9 mm pistol beside my sleeping bag. Like millions and millions of other armed citizens in this nation, I did not do this out of fear. I did this out of caution—the same reason I put a life preserver on my 10-year-old son as we canoed over lakes on that lovely adventure. As armed citizens, we hope for the best and prepare for the worst. This is what freedom is.

New York, however, has decided lawful armed citizens are the problem. Officials have now used crimes committed by those who are not lawfully carrying to justify this infringement on good citizens.

When asked about this new and onerous web of restrictions on lawful carry, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) recently said she and the state legislature wrote and quickly passed these Second Amendment infringements because the U.S. Supreme Court “destroyed the ability for a governor to be able to protect her citizens from people who carry concealed weapons anywhere they choose.” Hochul, like other anti-Second Amendment politicians, blames law-abiding gun owners for crimes even though crime data clearly shows that those with permits to carry concealed basically do not commit crimes.

On November 8, voters in New York and across this nation will have the chance to weigh in on whether they side with politicians like Hochul or whether they, instead, want their freedom.


Kamala Harris caricature
Kamala Harris caricature

If Only Kamala Harris Knew Something About Guns

Some of the loudest voices seeking to restrict our freedoms are, in fact, the most ignorant. One of these voices happens to also be the vice president of the United States.

Mainstream Media Blames Crime on Recent SCOTUS Decision

Some in the mainstream media seem to be insinuating that recent crimes are somehow the result of a recent Supreme Court decision.

NRA Releases Statement on Rahimi Decision

Today, in United States v. Rahimi, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the federal prohibition on firearms possession by individuals subject to domestic violence restraining orders.

A Declaration of Independence From Joe Biden

It is incumbent upon an electorate to decline to reelect a president who has failed in his civic responsibilities.

Murder Capital USA

Those aligned with Biden’s policies have failed in their basic duty to keep Americans safe. This is painfully evident in our nation’s capital.

These Gun Owners Say Good Things About Our Future

Women are embracing their Second Amendment rights like never before. Whatever their motivations, it’s worth looking at the impact this demographic change might portend.

Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.