An Unfavorable California Decision that May Later Bear Fruit

by
posted on December 8, 2021
california.jpeg

On November 30, the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld California’s ban on so-called “large-capacity” firearm magazines. In doing so, it reversed earlier rulings that found the restriction unconstitutional. This latest ruling, in the case of Duncan v. Bonta, was 7-4.

“The ban on legal possession of large-capacity magazines reasonably supports California’s effort to reduce the devastating damage wrought by mass shootings,” wrote Circuit Judge Susan Graber, a President Bill Clinton appointee.

In August of 2020, gun owners received a very positive decision from a three judge panel of the Ninth Circuit in the case then known as Duncan v. Becerra (the name changed after Rob Bonta replaced Xavier Becerra as California’s attorney general). This decision was an appeal from federal Judge Roger Benitez’s court concerning California’s “large-capacity” magazine (LCM) ban.

The August 2020 decision read, in part: “California’s near-categorical ban of LCMs strikes at the core of the Second Amendment—the right to armed self-defense. Armed self-defense is a fundamental right rooted in tradition and the text of the Second Amendment. Indeed, from pre-colonial times to today’s post-modern era, the right to defend hearth and home has remained paramount.”

The decision also ruled that firearm magazines are protected arms under the Second Amendment and that LCMs are commonly owned and typically used for lawful purposes

Benitez had also rendered another landmark decision when he ruled in Miller v. Bonta that the AR-15 is protected by the Second Amendment. This ruling is memorable for its opening sentence: “Like the Swiss Army Knife, the popular AR-15 rifle is a perfect combination of home defense weapon and homeland defense equipment.”

Because Duncan was already working its way through the Ninth Circuit and presented overlapping issues on the proper standard for evaluating Second Amendment cases, the Ninth Circuit delayed deciding the state’s appeal in Miller.

Of course, after losing Duncan at the Ninth Circuit before the three judge panel, the California attorney general persuaded the full Ninth Circuit Court to consider what is called an en banc appeal (in which a larger panel of judges hears the case again). This is typically the step where all favorable gun-rights decisions die in the Ninth Circuit.

True to form, California won before that en banc panel, with dissenting judges urging the U.S. Supreme Court to hear an appeal. The Supreme Court may well hear the case, although it is impossible to say with certainty. If so, the Justices could go along with Benitez’s broad recognition of LCMs as protected by the Second Amendment. Should that happen, the precedent could affect other pending cases as well, including those dealing with prohibitions on the AR-15 and other semiautomatic long guns. Whatever happens, we’ll keep you informed.

Clayton E. Cramer teaches history at a community college in Idaho that prefers anonymity.

Latest

Prohibited graphic
Prohibited graphic

Prohibited

If you’ve ever wondered why nonviolent felonies should disqualify someone from their Second Amendment rights for life, then you’re asking the same question a court just did.

The Red Tape of the Bureaucracy

Despite the Second Amendment’s plain language, there are still many places throughout the country in which it is nearly impossible for even the most conscientious citizen to follow the letter of the law. This is by design.

The Increasing Burden of Backdoor Gun Control

A mountain of fees, regulations and more is making it increasingly difficult for many law-abiding Americans to exercise their Second Amendment rights. This is what gun-control proponents want.

Biden to Create Anti-Second Amendment Federal Office

President Joe Biden is reportedly set to announce that his administration is creating a new federal office.

From the Editor | The Wildness of the Human Experience

Many people hide behind and project their ideological fantasies onto the political world. If only these same people would take a clear, honest look around them, they might just learn a thing or two.

President’s Column | It’s Your Most Fundamental Freedom — So Set The Record Straight.

As the Declaration of Independence says, all free people “are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights.” The first and most-fundamental of these is the right to arms to defend ourselves.

Interests



Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.