Biden’s Court-Packing Plans Canned, For Now

by
posted on December 16, 2021
48243932062_0656c59236_k.jpg
Gage Skidmore courtesy Flickr

In late 2019, five U.S. Senators, all Democrats, threatened to “restructure” (read “pack”) the U.S. Supreme Court if the Court went ahead with a challenge to New York’s gun-control laws.

That particular case was called “moot” by the high court. But the issue didn’t go away. It impacted the 2020 presidential election. Both then-candidate Joe Biden and Kamala Harris, at the time, would not say whether they were for adding justices to the U.S. Supreme Court or not.

Later, after Biden became president of the United States, he issued an executive action (one of almost 50 in his first 100 days) directing the formation of a commission to study the U.S. Supreme Court.

President Joe Biden’s (D) Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court recently, and unanimously, approved a nearly 300-page report. It has little to say about the “Membership and Size of the Court.” It devotes just one chapter—28 of the 300 pages—to this topic. Rather than making any formal recommendations for court packing, the commission simply laid out the arguments for and against it.

That commission’s conclusion said that “there is profound disagreement among Commissioners over whether adding Justices to the Supreme Court at this moment in time would be wise. As a Commission we have endeavored to articulate the contours of that debate as best as we understand them, without purporting to judge the weight of any of the arguments offered in favor or against calls to increase the size of the Court.”

The Wall Street Journal reported: “Because the commissioners disagreed strongly on the subject, the document takes the form of plainly laying out the arguments for and against court-packing at about equal length.”

The report’s measured tone on the topic and failure to formally recommend any plan for court packing is a welcome repudiation to the desires of certain politicians who seek to cynically grab power.

“A Biden court-packing scheme would be an American-altering progressive power grab. A power grab,” wrote America’s 1st Freedom Editor in Chief Frank Miniter during Biden’s presidential campaign.

Of course, the threat of court packing extends beyond that of the executive branch and into the legislature. It was not all so long ago that five senators actually had the gumption to outright threaten the high court with being “restructured.”

In that previously mentioned late-2019 “friend-of-the-court” brief, which The Wall Street Journal called an “enemy-of-the-court brief,” those five U.S. senators wrote: “The Supreme Court is not well. And the people know it. Perhaps the Court can heal itself before the public demands it be ‘restructured in order to reduce the influence of politics.’ Particularly on the urgent issue of gun control, a nation desperately needs it to heal.”

Clearly, these senators and President Biden want the Court to further their partisan agenda. Fortunately, the commission’s report signals this isn’t likely to happen.

Latest

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau

Confiscation in Canada

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's authoritarian zeal to disarm his citizens is a warning to any free people–and it shows how fundamentally important our constitutional protections are.

America's Rifle

Gun-control activists and politicians don't want citizens to know the truth about these semi-automatic rifles. So here is the history, and the contemporary facts, about these rifles.

The New Balance of Power

Almost as soon as the voting was over, President Biden once again said that he wants to sign a ban on pretty much every firearm sold in the U.S. Though he likely doesn't have the votes to do so in this Congress, this balance of power does give him some opportunities to go after our freedom.

The Story Behind the Sale of Barrett Firearms

“Today marks the beginning of a new chapter in the Barrett story,” says Ronnie Barrett.

Why the Legal Fight in Illinois Matters So Much

When a governor, along with a majority of a state’s legislators, decide to take a civil right from American citizens, they have decided to start a constitutional fight.

The Armed Citizen® January 27, 2023

True stories of the right to keep and bear arms.

Interests



Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.