First Gear | Optics Up For The Short/Light MSR Build

by
posted on January 8, 2017
first-gear_ar-build.jpg
A1F Staff

Before we get too immersed in news from the upcoming SHOT Show, we’re going to sneak in another part of our short/light MSR build. Just before a wee holiday break, we’d worked our way up to the barrel (from Faxon) from a dandy folder and stock combo, and selected some key internals and small components (here and here). Our trigger (from Timney by way of Brownells), charging handle and selector (both from AXTS) are also set. 

Next up is an optic and mount system. The first we expect some flack over: It may seem “retro” at the least, or just plain inadequate by some standards, but we think we can make the case. The latter is a no-brainer with the subtext of our project—light and short. “Short” doesn’t play perhaps, but “light” absolutely does, and a long track record and great performance made our choice easy. 

The optics and controls are typical Leupold, and that 1.5 power is better than you’d guess for up-close shooting. Just practice. Photo credit: A1F Staff

Leupold AR MOD-1 1.5-4x20 mm—Just three characters ought to make clear why we settled on this optic for our small/light MSR: “9.6,” as in ounces. We acknowledge that it’s a one-inch tube swimming in a 30, 34 and even 36 mm ocean, but if you take a look at the specifications of those larger optics, the unwelcome news is readily apparent: Roughly four ounces is the cost of a 30 mm tube with no magnification increase. 

“But won’t that 30 mm main tube be a lot brighter?” Not necessarily. We couldn’t find a single reference that would confirm anything more than a 5 percent advantage (all other things being equal), and the clarity of the math and explanations is, well, circuitous—we wonder if even that small margin is defensible, except at the extremes. What a bigger tube does get is larger, slightly more rugged components, and larger adjustment span. 

We figure the “Leupold” covers the first part (that whole “reputation” and “full lifetime guarantee” business) as an objection, and 5.56—properly mounted—parameterizes the second: We know anything beyond 300 yards is far more likely dependent on us and our ammunition than the optic. Guess we’ll need more practice—aw, darn. 

There’s another subtle benefit in the 1.5-4x, though it’s a tad obscure in this era of relatively pervasive 1x. We absolutely concur with the low magnification/both eyes open school of CQB, but 1.5x—combined with the forgiving eye box of the Leupold—is something we know works, too. Granted, 1x is easier, but it’s far more a matter of practice than anything else, and we’ve still saved those four or so ounces. 

We hate to call anything as rugged as our Leupold “dainty,” but nothing else fits: With controls we know and quality in which we have great confidence, we’ll trade any “one-inch” stigma for our lighter carry weight. 

Visit Leupold & Stevens at www.leupold.com.  

Warne QD “High” or “Extra High” 1” rings—Regular “First Gear” readers may recollect we’ve ID’d these as favorites before, and our reason for choosing them for our light/short build is a simple analogue: Tough and reliably excellent, we now cash in on virtually no extra material to trim several more ounces. 

Vertical splits and steel keys helps your optic and rings stay put. Photo credit: A1F Staff

Our optics/mount as spec’d will barely top a pound, but a couple of additional thoughts especially apply to our short/light rifle and 1.5-4x Leupold. Many of the Warnes are available in multiple heights; a “gotta-have” feature for many rifles, and especially for a flat-top MSR. But choosing yours may reward a little caution, and it may not be quite the no-brainer you expect. 

Mainly, this is due to a relatively complex interaction between head position, magnification and the eye relief of your scope. While the last two are dictated mostly by mathematics, the first is not: Length of the neck, and “depth” of the eyes in the cranium relative to cheek weld can vary enough to make “perfect!” for Shooter A sub-optimal, or even un-usable, for Shooter B. Our experience points to “Ultra High” as the best for most shooters on MSRs with a one-inch tube (and what Warne recommends), but about 15 percent seem to do better with the “Extra Highs” more usually associated with 30 mm. 

We have a theory (of course): Especially for both-eyes-open shooting on a non-intermediate eye relief scope, rapidly repeatable head position is a clear advantage, and going a little shorter on ring height helps with this for some shooters. Default to the taller set, but try them both if at all possible. 

Visit Warne at www.warnescopemounts.com. 

Part 1     Part 2      Part 3     Part 4     Part 5     Part 7     Part 8     Part 9

Latest

gun show
gun show

2022 NRA Annual Meetings And Exhibits In Houston, Texas

From entertainment to special events, it’s all happening in the Lone Star State, where NRA members will gather at the George R. Brown Convention Center May 27-29 to celebrate freedom and honor those who have served our country.

On Freedom’s Frontlines

In Ukraine, a vivid and inspirational example of the need for the right to keep and bear arms could not be more apparent.

The Armed Citizen® May 20, 2022

True stories of the right to keep and bear arms.

25 States Have Now Gotten Out of Our Way

Just over three decades ago, only on state had constitutional carry. Now, half the country has gotten out of the way of Americans' right to carry concealed.

From The Editor: Will More Europeans Go Pro-Gun Rights?

It is an open question whether, as everyone sees Ukrainian citizens picking up rifles to defend their lives and liberty from Russian troops, more Europeans will come to the conclusion that this is a right every law-abiding person needs.

President’s Column | Ukraine’s Example

For anyone who ever needed proof of how crucial gun rights are to our survival and our safety, I have just two words of advice: Remember Ukraine!



Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.