Local Libertarian Party Sues N.Y. Over Pistol Permitting Law

posted on August 18, 2015
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **

The Erie County Libertarian Party has filed a lawsuit against N.Y. Gov. Andrew Cuomo challenging the state’s pistol permit law. Called the Sullivan Act after the Tammany Hall politician who sponsored it in 1911, the law requires residents to obtain a permit to own any firearm small enough to be concealed. 

The group claims the law is “overly burdensome” for several reasons. One is cost: In NYC, fees total nearly $430—and since they’re non-refundable, you may be paying through the nose just to be told, “No.” Wait times are also at issue: NYC’s application states waits of up to eight months aren’t uncommon, and Rochester’s county clerk requests applicants not even bother asking about application status until after nine months. Furthermore, differences in policies and procedures—and who’s in charge of permitting—mean the odds of approval vary greatly between counties.

The suit is currently before U.S. District Judge Frank Geraci Jr.

Latest

10 Lies About Guns And Crime The Trump Administration Has Exposed
10 Lies About Guns And Crime The Trump Administration Has Exposed

Dispelling Anti-Gun Disinformation | Here Are 10 Lies About Guns And Crime The Trump Administration Has Exposed

Crime is a major problem in the United States, 66% of Americans believe, with 81% saying it is a major problem in large cities, according to an August 2025 poll by the Associated Press/NORC [previously the National Opinion Research Center].

The Greatest Second Amendment Victory in a Century

On July 4, 2025, Americans celebrated not only our nation’s independence, but also the restoration of our constitutional Second Amendment rights becoming unconstrained by burdensome and arbitrary fees.

Opening Salvo | More Evidence That Gun-Control Groups are Freaking Out

With the Trump administration’s law-and-order push showing America’s crime problem is clearly not the fault of lawfully armed citizens, gun-control groups are freaking out.

John Rich has a Song for Armed Citizens

John Rich's latest song is "The Righteous Hunter." It is a moving tune about standing up to stop those with evil intentions. It is a song for lawfully armed citizens.

This Department of Education Grant Could Change Things

The University of Wyoming’s Firearms Research Center has been awarded a nearly $1 million grant by the U.S. Department of Education to develop a nationwide program on the origins, meaning and implications of the Second Amendment.

From the Editor | Charlie Kirk Lived for Freedom

“Give me liberty, or give me death,” are the immortal words of Patrick Henry spoken on March 23, 1775, to the Second Virginia Convention in Richmond, Va. His impassioned words were a call to arms against British tyranny.  

Interests



Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.