Rare Revolutionary War Rifle Stolen Nearly 50 Years Ago Found in Barn Sale, Now in Philadelphia Museum

posted on November 11, 2019

Rifle photos courtesy of the Museum of the American Revolution.

A rare American flintlock rifle made in 1775—and stolen from a museum in 1971—has been recovered with the help of an antiques collector. It is now available for public viewing in a Philadelphia museum.

The five-foot-long “Pennsylvania rifle” belongs to the Pennsylvania Society of Sons of the Revolution (PSSR). The gun was stolen while on loan to the Valley Forge museum, according to the Smithsonian. A thief apparently pried open a display case with a crowbar or similar tool to steal the rifle shortly after the park opened on Oct. 26, 1971. A Boy Scout touring the museum noticed the theft soon afterward, but the valuable gun was never recovered.

The PSSR is loaning the rifle to Museum of the American Revolution in Philadelphia for a special exhibition. The gun’s return was celebrated with a ceremony at the museum Nov. 1 and at a PSSR formal event the next day. The Museum of the American Revolution is displaying the special rifle for the public in a “Cost of Revolution” exhibit through March 17, 2020.

“We had it at the Musket Ball, under cover. Nobody knew. We unveiled it and people went nuts—they jumped out of their seats to get a better view,” Ben Wolf, President of the PSSR, told America’s 1st Freedom in a phone interview. “It’s a special artifact—the detail on it is incredible! These things have gotten silly in value, but the bigger, more important point is that there is so much history to them. They have a story. They should be on display for generations to enjoy.”

The rifle is an example of the type militiamen posted with George Washington’s Continental Army would have used while camped in the Valley Forge area during the winter of 1777-78. The gun was significant to the success of the Revolutionary War because its long “rifled” barrel added spin on the discharging bullet, making for a far more accurate shot at longer distances. British troops using smooth-bore barrels were unprepared for the guerrilla-warfare tactics that the new rifle technology allowed American soldiers to use.

The flintlock was made by Johann Christian Oerter, a Pennsylvania master gunsmith whose work is highly sought by collectors, according to The New York Times. Oerter is thought to have made only about 16 rifles a year from age 19 until his death at age 29 in 1777. The gun has a fine brass-wire inlay on its stock, and Oerter’s name is engraved on the barrel, along with the year and location of the rifle’s creation. The Times article noted that another Oerter rifle with a raised carving on the stock fetched more than $200,000 at auction.

Antiques collector Kelly Kinzle recovered the stolen gun by buying it at a “barn sale.” He told The Philadelphia Inquirer he originally thought it was a reproduction: “My first inclination was that it had to be fake, because the real gun isn’t going to show up in a barn in today’s world. Things like that are already in collections.” Research led him to believe otherwise, however, so he turned it over to the FBI, who returned it to the PSSR. The culprit of the theft is still unknown, though the FBI’s investigation is reportedly ongoing.


AMA Logo
AMA Logo

The AMA Should Know Better

Over the years, the AMA has supported just about every kind of gun-control plan you could imagine; from bans on “assault weapons” to bans on handguns to waiting periods for gun purchasers.

Independence Day Reminds Us That Freedom Needs Safekeeping

Freedom is a gift. America’s Freedom was purchased with the blood of patriots who fought and died so we could be free.

Déjà Vu: Biden Doubles Down On Weaponizing ATF

Rather than nominating a respected, veteran law-enforcement agent to run the ATF, Biden once again prefers a puppet who will pursue a partisan gun-control agenda.

A Short History of the Semi-Automatic Firearm

Follow the journey and development of firearms to the recent models of the 21st century, and you'll see that the politicians who tell us citizens should not own these guns don't know their history.

Gun Skills: Next-Level Dry Practice

For dry practice to be truly effective, you need to practice more than just easy, controlled shots. Here's how to practice up to a defensive level.

Warrior Systems Manufacturing’s WSM15

If excellence in the AR-15 platform is what you are looking for, try Warrior Systems Manufacturing's WSM15. This is a solid and accurate rifle with great aesthetics and a reasonable price tag.

Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.