Stolen Rifle Returned After 20 Years in Washington Town’s Police Evidence Storage, Long Waits Typical Nationwide

by
posted on October 25, 2019
stevens22_evidence.jpg

Twenty years after a Stevens .22 caliber rifle was stolen from an area resident, police in Kelso, Wash., discovered the owner had been deceased for three years. They returned the rifle to the next of kin, the owner’s eldest son who “had no idea” the gun even existed.

It took 10 years for the prosecuting attorney to give permission to release the rifle and another 10 years for the police to do so.

“Around 2009, KPD received a property release from the [prosecuting attorney’s] office for this case, meaning the property could go back to its original owner,” the Kelso Police Department said in a Facebook post Oct. 2. “For some reason unbeknownst to our current Property and Evidence Clerk … the rifle was still here at KPD [in 2019].”

That the stolen rifle was recovered at all seems to be unusual. A Kelso police captain told a news reporter: “It’s not very common for stolen property to be found and returned to its rightful owner.”

The 20-year wait for the rifle’s return seems to be less unusual. A long delay for personal property kept in evidence to be returned seems common, particularly for firearms.

“Federal laws should be put in place to require prosecutors and police to return private property faster,” Paul Paradis said in a phone interview with America’s 1st Freedom. Paradis is a 28-year retired ballistic forensics expert and criminologist with the Colorado State Public Defenders’ Office, which has 21 regional offices. He also owns a gun shop that was once burglarized, so he feels he has experienced the issues surrounding evidence retention from both sides.

Paradis noted that a judge can order officials to conduct their evidence testing and return evidence to its owner immediately, but few people can afford the attorneys’ fees that method would require and often don’t know it’s an option.

Are firearms returned less often than other evidence? “Oh, yes,” Paradis responded. “And in some places, like California, if [police] get their hands on a gun, they look for any reason to destroy it.”

According to one source, police departments can hold onto personal property in evidence “anywhere from the closing of the case until the end of time.” That source also notes:

  • Few state guidelines exist in the U.S. to determine when evidence should be returned, retained, or disposed of, so it’s left up to prosecutors and police. Many prosecutors and police also have few guidelines in place.
  • Many police departments prefer to hold onto evidence for later legal challenges, particularly now that DNA testing can influence closed cases.
  • Even if the evidence can be returned for other reasons, low staffing may prevent police from following through.

In a detailed investigation of police’s retention of personal property, several district attorneys told reporters the system to return property is “chaotic [and] ‘ridiculous.’” They also said “none of the parties involved in property seizures communicate effectively, leaving property owners without a way to recover their things even when prosecutors make it clear they no longer need the items.”

The Kelso, Wash., police declined an interview request for this story; they also did not respond to a request for a copy of their evidence procedures in time for publication.

Latest

The Armed Citizen
The Armed Citizen

The Armed Citizen® February 23, 2024

True stories of the right to keep and bear arms.

ATF Gloats Over Increased FFL Revocations

Biden has repeatedly used the ATF to go after lawful gun dealers and now, the ATF seems more than happy to publicize that fact.

Biden is Trying to Export His Gun-Control Plans to Your State

Joe Biden is making 2024 all about infringing upon the Second Amendment; as such, he is also seeking to bring his federal gun-control office to the state level.

America Loses Its Oldest Factory—Yeah, a Gun Factory

Gone is America’s oldest factory. Silenced are the machines and gone are the jobs for the men and women in a small town in upstate New York.

From The Editor: The Funny Thing About Range Rules

The NRA rules of gun safety begin with three mantras that provide a foundation for all that follows. These very rules also offer a foundation for much more.

Standing Guard | Farewell And Thank You

The NRA isn’t a building in Washington D.C., or anywhere else. It’s an idea, and an ideal, that transcends who we are as individuals. It’s millions of Americans who believe fighting for freedom is the highest calling.



Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.