The Atlantic Suggests Using an Anti-Gun Narrative to Supplant the Second Amendment

by
posted on November 2, 2019
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
supreme-court-blg-exterior.jpg

Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons, Richard Gillin/CC BY-SA 2.0.

An opinion piece in The Atlantic, titled “A Constitutional Case for Gun Control,” showed how tangled the mainstream media’s narrative on guns is nationally.

The opinion article was written by two Yale Law School students. Like many on the anti-gun left, they are clearly worried that a majority of U.S. Supreme Court justices will honestly interpret the Second Amendment of the U.S. Bill of Rights when they rule on New York State Rifle & Pistol Association Inc. v. City of New York sometime next year.

These two Yale Law School students write:

“Gun-control advocates need their own constitutional narrative, one that incorporates a broader conception of self-defense into its vision. Since Heller, the Court has drawn a straight line connecting the broader, constitutionally grounded right to self-defense to the more specific right to individual gun ownership. But defense of oneself and one’s family can be pursued in a variety of ways. An individual right to gun ownership offers one path, deputizing all people to defend themselves with a firearm at their side. Gun regulation offers another such path to self-defense, one vastly more efficacious and preferred by the American public. It represents a mode of preemptive self-defense, whereby the state is tasked by its citizens with limiting access to deadly force.”

These two students are so entangled in the left’s narratives about guns that they’re asking us to suspend all we know about the nature of our rights, including why the Founders put the Second Amendment in the U.S. Bill of Rights, so that some fabricated narrative pushing a collective-rights myth can legally supplant protections of our individual freedom.

They also want us to forget—and the mainstream media is helping them by not fairly reporting these facts—all of the evidence proving that more guns does equal less crime.

They go on to argue that “[g]un-control advocates must reclaim the Constitution from the pro-gun lobby.”

The thing is, their method isn’t an attempt to “reclaim the Constitution.” It is an attempt to rewrite the Constitution without going through the constitutional amendment process the document mandates. They want a majority of U.S. Supreme Court justices to usurp the liberty of the people in order to make way for centralized government power they crave.

For a detailed analysis of this upcoming U.S. Supreme Court case, read the NRA’s friend-of-the-court brief on New York State Rifle & Pistol Association Inc. v. City of New York. Also, check back here, as we’ll keep you up to date on this important case and on other important issues related to your rights.

Latest

Screenshot 2025 11 10 At 10.31.10 AM (1)
Screenshot 2025 11 10 At 10.31.10 AM (1)

This U.S. Marine Corps Colonel Has a Veterans Day Message

The Marine Corps’ birthday is November 10, and this year marks the 250th birthday of the Marine Corps. To commemorate this, and Veterans Day, we're bringing you this moving and important video with Col. Miles Burdine, USMC (Ret.).

The Trump Administration is Changing D.C. Culture

Jeanine Pirro, the U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia, is reconciling the enforcement of laws in the District with the Second Amendment.

An Off-Year Election of Setbacks for Freedom

In this off-year election, all of the races were different—and will have very different impacts on citizens’ Second Amendment-protected rights—but a far-left, very anti-gun sweep was a common theme.

Glock Retools

In order to ban many Glock semi-automatic pistols and some others, California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) signed Assembly Bill 1127.

The Armed Citizen® October 31, 2025

True stories of the right to keep and bear arms

Minnesota Capital Comes for America’s Rifle

The St. Paul City Council recently introduced an “assault-weapons” ban ordinance.



Get the best of America's 1st Freedom delivered to your inbox.